About Us

Our Story

 Welcome to Formaggio Pizzeria — Columbus’s home for NY style, authentic, handcrafted pizza and Stromboli made with love. Since opening in [2025], our mission has been to serve our community by using only the finest ingredients, time-tested recipes, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you join us for carryout, or delivery, we treat every customer like family.

We take pride in:

    - Fresh dough stretched by hand daily

    -  Homemade sauces

    - The finest Italian cheeses money can buy 

    -  Locally sourced toppings wherever possible

    - Commitment to using only the highest quality ingredients on our pizzas 

    - Friendly service with a local spirit

    - Come taste the difference — great pizza, made right in Columbus.

    - Where catering is made easy, say goodbye to kitchen chaos - we will handle the cooking so you can savor the moments that matter

    - Be it a tasty family dinner or a corporate lunch. Visit us on Georgesville Road or place an order online. We can't wait to serve you!